The Failure of AI

In the early days of AI, scientists thought they would be able to build an intelligent computer by the end of the 20th century. This raised various fears about computers eventually taking over the world, and human beings replaced by robots.
Not only this did not happen yet but we are very far from this!
But what is even worse is that we are now following a somewhat opposite trend. There are many tasks at which humans are far better than computers, but instead of trying to build better algorithms for these tasks, people are now trying to find ways to better make use of human intelligence, or rather to automate this usage!

Two examples of this: Luis von Ahn's "Artificial artificial intelligence" and Amazon's "Mechanical Turk".

Luis von Ahn has designed a couple of internet games whose purpose is to make players perform useful tasks such as labeling images. Amazon is taking this to the industrial scale (although not as a game anymore) by allowing people to design programs which include calls to web services which are actually executed by paid humans (e.g. your program calls "translate(text)" and the text is sent to someone who translates the text and return the result)!

Update (21/12/2006): I found a related article in the Boston Globe, citing other examples of the same kind, such as Mozes Mob, a cell phone Q&A service powered by humans.

Comments

[FICO]

I don't think this is a failure so much as a renewed recognition that there is an A in AI - Artificial. To me artificial intelligence should be different from human intelligence. I think the idea of load balancing between people and computers is a great one - see http://www.edmblog.com/weblog/2006/07/load_balancing_.html

[Olivier Bousquet]

The title of my post was intentionally provocative.
But I agree with you: combining both human and artificial intelligence(s) is probably a promising direction.

[Matthew Hurst]

In the early days of AI there was solid motivation to study the area both by better understanding and to better understand human intelligence. This part of the programme has been lost in the vast array of niche areas of study that are currently associated with AI. If one associates the 'completion' of AI research with a full(er) understanding of human intelligence, then one wouldn't be surprised at the rate of success.

Personally, I believe in the inevitable appearance of strong AI. It wouldn't surprise me, however, that it will come from an unexpected direction. That is to say, not out of academic research labs, but out of some highly capitalized business area such as computer games or humanoid robotics.

[Jean-Marc Kerisit]

I agree with you: the totalitary vision of Artificial Intelligence has definitely failed (hopefully for ever); and time is coming for a more modest AI dream: take benefinit of all technologies to propose to human beings developing and enhancing their intelligence power thanks to ergonomic cooperation with algorithms, systems and machines. Would AI enable us to become more human ? This seems to me a hopeful question to raise...

[Amelia27Vi]

Very oft it falls out that you do not have time to compose the thesis pdf close to this good post. Some students make a big problem from that, because they do not know anything about thesis writing services, but I will give you knowledge about the pfroper ways to detect the superior buy dissertation service and how to buy a thesis paper in a cheap way.

[Custom Essay]

Hi,
Thanks for such a timely post. I guess your article have covered all the grounds related to this issue. I liked your efforts and hard work.

[Dissertation Help]

Hello,
Excellent post, I really enjoy reading this article, thank you so much for sharing it.

[A level coursework]

Hi,
This is inspiring; I am very pleased by this post. Nice info at this post thanks!!! I really like it

[Assignment Help]

Hi,
Thank you for sharing information in the blog. You are really doing a good work. I personally like this blog and appreciates your efforts.

[Soft Cialis]

I really like this blog, you are very good making them. I say that the issue discussed in this blog is quite interesting and of high quality.

[Custom Thesis Writing]

this kind of blog always useful for blog readers, it helps people during research. your post is one of the same for blog readers.

http://www.eduthesis.com/

[Custom Thesis Writing]

this kind of blog always useful for blog readers, it helps people during research. your post is one of the same for blog readers.

[Coursework Writing]

I found nice resources in your post for my coursework.

[Condos For Sale in Costa Rica]

I want information about the kind of websites most people spend their
time online. If its email, news, searching, watching media
content(youtube), social networking(myspace)....

If you could also break it down by popularity and percentage that
would be great. thanks.

[virus classification]

Who don't wear a jeans!!!!????
Everyone!!!!!!!!
It's the best thing in this world!!!

[thesis writing]

i am searching many blogs and others sources for complete my thesis writing assignment for holiday work i like your blog so informative and knowledgeable keep your blog updated.

[buy cialis]

I came across your blog via google when I was looking for a way to cover a corkboard with fabric. Thank you SO much for the step by step instructions. I am in love with my "new" bulletin board and will be sure to do this fun and easy craft again. I tried to do the buttons as well on my push pins, but to no avail, they didn't work. Do you have some advice for those? Maybe I didn't use enough glue? Maybe I should have used thumb tacks in lieu of push pins? I would love your advice!

[sildenafil citrate]

Just working through some notes on ethics and social networks and I thought I'd share the following paragraph that I've been working on - because it seems counter-intuitive at first.

There is a growing consensus that comments posted in social networks are not ‘in the public domain’ and that researchers should seek permission to use them. Researchers should also remember that because the internet is so readily searchable, they should avoid using literal quotes from social network discussions (in most cases) as this will potentially reveal who the respondent is.

In many codes of ethics and in a growing number of laws, the intention/expectation of the person making a post is important in determining what can be done with that post. In terms of privacy there are two issues. The first is that if a researcher has to join a network to see the post, then the person making the post is doing so in the expectation that they are talking to genuine members of the community, not to professional researchers or journalists. The second that is when somebody makes, say, 200 posts in their status bar over the course of a year, they did not have the expectation that all their quotes would be brought back together as a single corpus for investigation.

[cheap computer]

I think its not fair to compare article intelligence with human intelligence. I don't agree with the writer that its the failure of artificial intelligence and it is doing its work but will take time to reach highest level.
For used desktops log on to
http://www.electrocomputerwarehouse.com

[Round and Brown]

issues. The first is that if a researcher has to join a network to see the post, then the person making the post is doing so in the expectation that they are talking to genuine members of the community, not to

[costa rica best investment]

Costa Rica is an excellent country to invest in real estate its economy is very stable, being a peaceful country and have their exuberant nature makes it much more attractive to invest

[Jordan Retro 8]

Alter your attitude and you can alter your life. Good luck to you!

[viagra online]

Mmmm, looks absolutely delicious. I used to look forward to Caribbean black cake at weddings and other special events. Then I became a vegan, and that was the end of that. I'd love to sample this! Any chance you'd be willing to share the recipe? :)

[Jordan 5]

I would like to live to study, and not study to live.

[ativan]

Can you give me this game link?